Skip to content

Independent Dog and Cat Food Rankings

We score 47 pet foods from 19 brands on two proprietary indices: the IDNM, which measures nutrient density, and the IPFI, which audits ingredient purity. Every score is calculated by algorithm.

Cão energético capturando frisbee
0–100IDNM/IPFI TECHNICAL SCORE
COVERAGECATS AND DOGS
METHODIDNM + IPFI
FOCUSDEMANDING OWNERS
ANALYSISSCIENCE-BASED

By the numbers

47Foods Scored

Scores calculated by the IDNM and IPFI indices

19Brands Ranked

All measured against the same technical criteria

20Cat Foods

Full ranking with a technical score

27Dog Foods

Full ranking with a technical score

Cat food ranking

#1
86.5

Purina Pro Plan

Purina Pro Plan Sensitive Skin & Stomach

See full analysis
Adult Verified data Gold Evidence
What we like
conservantes naturais
taurina declarada
probióticos
Purina Pro Plan Sensitive Skin & Stomach
Value for Money64.4
#2
85.8
What we like
conservantes naturais
taurina declarada
probióticos
Nulo Freestyle Cat & Kitten
Value for Money57.6
#3
What we like
conservantes naturais
taurina declarada
probióticos
Instinct Original Raw Coated Cat
Value for Money71.4
#4
84.9
What we like
conservantes naturais
taurina declarada
EPA/DHA declarado
Tiki Cat Born Carnivore
Value for Money52.9
#5
84.4

Hill's Science Diet

Hill's Science Diet Perfect Weight Cat

See full analysis
Adult Estimated data Gold Evidence
What we like
taurina declarada
EPA/DHA declarado
L-carnitina
Hill's Science Diet Perfect Weight Cat
Value for Money51.3
#6
80.8

Purina Pro Plan

Purina Pro Plan Indoor Care

See full analysis
Adult Verified data Gold Evidence
What we like
conservantes naturais
taurina declarada
carnes frescas
Purina Pro Plan Indoor Care
Value for Money59
#7
79.9

Hill's Science Diet

Hill's Science Diet Adult Indoor Cat

See full analysis
Adult Verified data Gold Evidence
What we like
taurina declarada
L-carnitina
carnes frescas
Hill's Science Diet Adult Indoor Cat
Value for Money51.4
#8
79.2
What we like
conservantes naturais
taurina declarada
L-carnitina
Blue Buffalo Tastefuls Indoor
Value for Money58.9
#9
78.5
What we like
taurina declarada
probióticos
Taste of the Wild Rocky Mountain Feline
Value for Money62.1
#10
78.2

Purina Pro Plan

Purina Pro Plan High Protein Adult

See full analysis
Adult Verified data Gold Evidence
What we like
conservantes naturais
taurina declarada
probióticos
Points of concern
proteína anônima
Purina Pro Plan High Protein Adult
Value for Money61.8

Learn about pet nutrition

O gato ruivo de Churchill e a genética do pelo laranja
NUTRITION

O gato ruivo de Churchill e a genética do pelo laranja

Churchill quis que sempre houvesse um gato ruivo em Chartwell, e o atual é o sétimo. A exigência da cor tem uma consequência genética escondida.

Read article
4 raças de cachorro que tinham emprego de verdade —
NUTRITION

4 raças de cachorro que tinham emprego de verdade —

O Rottweiler carregava a bolsa do açougueiro no pescoço. Terra Nova, Husky e São Bernardo também tinham função antes de existir cão de estimação.

Read article
Gato que gosta de água existe: o Turco Van e o pelo
NUTRITION

Gato que gosta de água existe: o Turco Van e o pelo

O Turco Van entra na água por vontade própria, e não é personalidade: a raça nasceu sem subpelo, e é essa ausência que deixa o pelo hidrorrepelente.

Read article
Value-for-Money Filter

Quality that fits the budget

Add the value-for-money filter to your search and find technically excellent foods at the lowest possible spend.

Start a personalized search
Our Methodology

How is the score calculated?

Technical Analysis

We assess how bioavailable the ingredients are, focusing on where the protein comes from and on the presence of synthetic additives. Foods made with fresh meat and no dyes start from a higher base score.

  • • Protein Purity
  • • Ash Content
  • • Ingredient Meta-analysis

Profile Fit

Every formula is tested against the specific needs of age and physiological state (neutered, senior, puppy or kitten). The score reflects how well the food delivers what the label promises.

  • • Taurine Levels
  • • Urinary pH Control
  • • Caloric Density

Value for Money

We do not reward luxury alone. We cross technical quality with market price to find products that deliver real health at a fair price to the buyer.

  • • Price per Kilo
  • • Yield per Serving
  • • Retail Availability

Understand our project

The technical score (0 to 100) is a weighted average of the IDNM (Minimum Nutrient Density Index), which measures the nutritional quality of the recipe on a dry-matter basis, and the IPFI (Ingredient Purity Index), which audits label transparency and the quality of the protein and fat sources. The formula is (IDNM × 0.55) + (IPFI × 0.45) and the calculation is 100% algorithmic.
The best food is the one with the highest technical score for your pet's profile. My Pet Magazine publishes separate rankings for cats and dogs, and the recommendation changes with age, neutering, size and health condition. Use the personalized ranking to see the top of the list for your species, and always confirm the choice with a veterinarian.
IDNM stands for Minimum Nutrient Density Index. It is the proprietary My Pet Magazine algorithm that calculates the nutrient density of a food on a dry-matter basis, worth up to 100 points. It adds up protein, fat, carbohydrates and ash against the AAFCO and FEDIAF target ranges, penalizing excess carbohydrates and rewarding high-quality protein.
My Pet Magazine is an independent project. We earn a small commission through affiliate links when you buy a food through our site. This does not change the price for you and does not influence our scores — the algorithm is 100% mathematical and based on labels, with no commercial interference.
Our ranking shows the best foods on the market on technical grounds, for cats and for dogs. Every animal is unique, though: age, neutering, size and health conditions change the recommendation. Always consult a veterinarian before switching your pet's diet.